Fat Talk: Why You Do it and What It Does To You
Guest blog post submitted by Jennifer Pereira, RD, LD, CSCS, president of Nutrition Paradox. March 9, 2010.
Ever notice how you might ‘feel fat’ on some days more than others? Chances are your body doesn’t change, but your mood does. Fat feelings are a scapegoat for real feelings. It is just hard to see past them to what is really going on.
I know it feels very real. I know you ‘feel’ very fat when you are doing this internal and external fat talk. The thing is, there is no great measure of what objectively qualifies as fat. BMI charts are deeply flawed–I recently read an article stating these charts would show Brad Pitt to be overweight, and George Clooney to be obese.
Weight charts were developed in the early 1900’s by The Metropolitan Life Insurance Company. Since they were trying to determine mortality risk associated with weight, these charts were based on weighing dead people. Does not seem like a valid tool at all.
I know what you really use to determine your fatness, though. Your eyes, or the way your clothes feel, etc. What you need to understand is people from 82 lbs. to 302 lbs. have these fat feelings. The feeling you are fat has nothing to do with your weight. It has only to do with your head.
There are also people on a broad weight spectrum who feel good in their bodies. Jennifer Lopez and Beyonce do not apologize for their curves–they own them. Marilyn Monroe certainly seemed comfortable in her skin.
There are two problems with fat talk:
1. It keeps you from figuring out what is really bothering you.
2. It makes you more likely to do weird things with food (restrict, binge, etc.)
You think that if you are mean enough to yourself, it will help you eat less and lose weight. Once the weight is off, you would be happy all of the time. That is not what happens, though. You just feel really bad. Which makes you more likely to emotionally eat. You might restrict first, but ultimately you will likely overeat in response to this negative self talk.
This cycle of self loathing and guilt gets constantly repeated. Ugh! So I ask you this: How is this fat talk working out for you? Can you identify with what I am saying here? If so, you are ready for the definition of insanity…
Insanity: doing the same thing over and over and expecting a different result.
So ask yourself a few questions:
1. Do you know absolutely, beyond a shadow of a doubt, that you are fat? (Hint: the tools we use to measure this are faulty)
2. What would you feel if you found out the weight you are today would always be your weight–no more, no less, for the rest of your life?
3. Who would you be if you didn’t have the thought “I am fat”? What would life be like if that never entered your mind or your conversations?
There is a tremendous freedom that comes from accepting your body. You have all this time available to think about more important things. You start to pay attention to your life in this present moment. It makes you more normal with food. It makes you better able to honor the physical differences in those around you. It makes you more loving towards yourself–and if you are not going to do it, who is?
Visit Jennifer’s Web site at http://www.healthylifestylebalance.com/.






April 4th, 2010 at 10:03 am
I so agree with this! I also feel that we shouldn’t look at aging in such a negative light, either. Things that happen naturally should be celebrated. I don’t know why we set ourselves up for failure like this. I have to admit I’m guilty of it myself at times, but I’m trying to change myself and to influence others to change, too.
This is a blog entry I wrote about this subject. (You can start about halfway down the page.) http://andthentherewasthatonetime.blogspot.com/2008/11/hb-to-me-and-melissa.html
April 6th, 2010 at 7:18 am
I am so happy to have stumbled upon this. I couldn’t agree more with your message. I am so tired of society and seeing the words “Lose weight” everywhere! I actually canceled my cable a few months ago because I could not stand to see any more plastic surgery shows on TV and being “told” what my body should look like if I want to be happy with myself.
Thank you so much for this, I plan on sharing this website with all my friends.
Sincerely,
Tiffani
April 6th, 2010 at 1:34 pm
I have always had a poor outlook on my body image. Somedays I feel beautiful and my outward appearence doesn’t bother me and other days I hate what I see in the mirror. I feel this way because I would like to be noticed and not look at as the ‘fat friend’. Now I see that your body image is important but it’s not the top priority anymore because being able to value who you are can take you further in life.
April 12th, 2010 at 1:54 pm
Kimi–I agree with aging being accepted. There is a beautiful picture from Dove that shows a beautiful, wrinkled woman–you will never look at wrinkles the same. Fear of wrinkles makes twenty-somethings worry they have them and get procedures to reduce them. Both fat and aging fears need to be re-examined in our culture. There is beauty in everything.
Tiffani–I am so impressed with your resolve, you did the right thing! TV and magazines measurably affect a person’s body image.
Azriel–If anyone around you considers you the ‘fat friend’, then they have issues. I know for myself, when I had body image issues I was judgmental of others. Now that I am comfortable in my skin, I see all shapes as beautiful, and I see people for their internal vs. external value. So if someone judges you based on your appearance, it is probably not someone you’d want to be around.
April 12th, 2010 at 10:17 pm
[...] recently wrote an article for a site promoting the end of fat talk. I’m pretty sure you know what talk I’m [...]
April 22nd, 2010 at 10:25 pm
Great article!….thank you!
April 22nd, 2010 at 10:26 pm
Great article!